11th Jan 2024 Editorial

"Vikalp Sangam Manifesto for a Just, Equitable, and Sustainable India"

Introduction:

  • India faces multiple crises: unemployment, social and cultural strife, ecological collapse, erosion of democratic rights.
  • Recent incidents highlight the severity of the situation, including protests, natural disasters, conflicts, and suppression of democratic voices.
  • Similar global crises are occurring, emphasizing the need for solutions.

 

 

Initiatives for Change:

  • Vikalp Sangam, a national platform, brings together 85 movements for ecological food production, water management, communitybased energy, education, health, and more.
  • The manifesto aims at the 2024 general election, calling for policy shifts to support alternative approaches.
  • Vikalp Sangam has a decadelong history of assemblies, stories of positive change, and advocacy for policy changes.

 

Economic Focus:

  • The manifesto addresses the unemployment crisis, emphasizing small manufacturing, crafts, value added agriculture, and extending rural employment guarantees to urban areas.
  • Calls for reserving goods and services for handmade and small manufacturing to make alternative approaches viable.
  • Examples on Vikalp Sangam’s website showcase success stories of rural revival and dignified livelihoods.

 

SocioPolitical Reforms:

  • Advocates curbs on the black economy, reduction in income inequality, wealth and inheritance taxation, basic income, and pensions for all workers.
  • Seeks decentralization of financial and legal powers, comprehensive accountability laws, and revival of independent institutions.
  • Demands the repeal of laws like Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and The National Security Act.

 

Social Inclusion and Dialogue:

  • Expresses concern about interfaith and interethnic conflicts, hate speech, and vulnerabilities of minorities.
  • Calls for forums of dialogue, restoring coexistence, and prioritizing marginalized sections in public and private institutions.
  • Seeks 6% of GDP for education, community health processes, and preventive healthcare, totaling 3% of GDP.

 

Environmental Focus:

  • Urges a national land and water policy, communityled conservation, and collective rights to natural resources.
  • Calls for organic farming by 2040, reduction in toxic products, and phasing out fossil fuels and nuclear power by 2030.
  • Recommends a National Environment Commissioner with independent constitutional status.

 

Climate Crisis Priority:

  • Stresses the need for greater allocation to help communities adapt to the impacts of the climate crisis.
  • Urges a rollback of weakened environmental impact assessment and forest clearance processes.

 

Challenges and Historical Context:

  • The manifesto presents a 21point charter backed by documented examples on Vikalp Sangam’s website.
  • Past attempts in 2019 resulted in some parties incorporating recommendations, but implementation remains a challenge.
  • Emphasizes the need for citizen awareness, proactivity, and assertiveness in influencing decisions affecting their lives.

 

 

 

Influence of Grassroots Movements:

  • References examples like Mendha Lekha and Dalit women farmers showcasing direct and accountable democracy, economic selfreliance, and sociocultural equality.
  • Encourages citizens to assert their voice and influence decisions, particularly emphasizing the role of the large youth population.

 

Conclusion:

  • The Vikalp Sangam Manifesto offers a comprehensive roadmap for addressing India’s crises, emphasizing grassroots initiatives and policy level shifts.

Calls for citizen engagement and vigilance in ensuring the implementation of proposed changes for a just, equitable, and sustainable future.

Escalation of Conflict in the Middle East

Spread of Conflict to Multiple Fronts

  1. Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, and Iran Affected
  • Gaza conflict extends to Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, and Iran.
  • Israeli drone strike targets Hamas office in Beirut, killing deputy leader Saleh alArouri.
  • Explosions in Kerman, Iran, raise suspicions of Israeli involvement.

 

  1. U.S. Targeted Killings in Baghdad

    U.S. announces targeted killing of an Iranaffiliated militia leader in Baghdad.

    Militia accused of attacking American targets during Gaza war.

 

 

  1. Red Sea Skirmishes with Houthis
  • Ongoing skirmishes in the Red Sea involving Houthis targeting commercial shipping.
  • Houthis demand urgent humanitarian assistance for Palestinians in Gaza.

 

#Escalation in Gaza and West Bank

  1. Israeli Operations and Humanitarian Crisis
  • Over 22,000 Palestinians killed in Gaza, primarily women and children, in the last three months.
  • Nearly two million Palestinians displaced, marking the largest displacement in history.

 

  1. Israeli Troop Expansion to West Bank
  • Israeli military operations expand to the West Bank.
  • Calls from Israeli cabinet Ministers for the cleansing of Gaza and resettlement with Jewish settlers.

 

#Netanyahu’s Dilemma and Lack of Strategy

Netanyahu’s Escalation Dilemma

  • Netanyahu faces challenges with little success in Gaza despite mass killings.
  • No prominent Hamas leaders apprehended, and ground fighting continues.

 

Lack of Vision and Strategy

    Absence of a clear vision or strategy from major players in the conflict.

    Israel lacks clarity on war aims, Gaza management postwar, and no mention of a longerterm peace process.

 

#Role of the U.S. and Saudi Arabia

U.S. Policy and Lack of Progress

    U.S. offers total political and military support to Israel.

    Biden administration criticized for ineffectiveness on the ground.

 

Call for Saudi Arabian Leadership

    Urgent need for Saudi Arabia to play a pivotal role in ushering peace.

    Saudi Arabia’s regional and global standing can make its views influential.

 

Regional Cooperation and Warning

     Lack of voice and leadership from Arab states.

     The responsibility for peace lies with Saudi Arabia, urging robust initiatives.

     West Asian rulers and people urged to unite for regional interests or face the consequences of conflict.

 

This editorial summary highlights the complex and volatile situation in the Middle East, involving multiple fronts, escalating tensions, and the need for proactive regional leadership, particularly from Saudi Arabia, to address the crisis and prevent further escalation.

  1. Background and Immediate Trigger:
  • Incipient tensions between India and Maldives surface after derogatory remarks about PM Modi on social media.
  • Maldivian government distances itself from remarks, suspends ministers, and President departs for Beijing.
  • Initial reaction may be seen as a minor issue, but deeper dimensions warrant attention.

 

 

  1. Strategic Dimension and Maritime Security:
  • Maldives, with 27 coral atolls and a vast exclusive economic zone, is crucial for India’s maritime security.
  • Indian Navy recognizes the significance, but a “continental fixation” hinders a comprehensive maritime strategy.
  • Historical context highlights the importance of Indian Ocean territories and the need for a proactive approach.

 

  1. Diplomatic Approach and Regional Dynamics:
  • Maldives’ politics influenced by hypernationalism, religious fervor, and IndiaChina rivalry.
  • Questions raised about India’s response to signs of hostility and the cancellation of the GMR contract in 2011.
  • China’s influence and Pakistan’s role considered, but India’s diplomatic approach and condescending attitudes also examined.

 

  1. Geopolitical Competition and IndoPacific Dynamics:
  • Shift in focus needed from border disputes to larger geopolitical competition with China.
  • Proximity advantage of India over China in the Indian Ocean Region highlighted.
  • Importance of friendly neighbors during crises underscored, contrasting China’s maritime footholds in the region.

 

  1. Maritime Diplomacy and SAGAR Doctrine:
  • Urgent need for better utilization of maritime diplomacy as a vital instrument.
  • Historical challenges in responding to maritime neighbors’ requests underscored.
  • SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region) slogan lacks a comprehensive doctrine; calls for fleshing out as a new maritime strategy.

Conclusion:

The IndiaMaldives diplomatic episode unveils strategic, diplomatic, and geopolitical dimensions.

It urges a comprehensive maritime strategy, emphasizing the significance of maritime diplomacy, and highlights the need for a refined approach in dealing with regional neighbors.

The episode serves as a valuable lesson for India to navigate the evolving IndoPacific dynamics effectively.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments