Addressing India's Accelerating Food-Price Inflation and Nutritional Crisis
Introduction
- India, the fastest-growing large economy globally, is grappling with the challenge of soaring food-price inflation.
- This issue has persisted since 2019 and reached an alarming level in July 2023 when annual inflation surpassed 11%, the highest in a decade.
- The consequences of such persistent inflation are severe, potentially leading to a significant portion of the population struggling to afford a nutritious diet.
Alarming Statistics on Food Affordability
- The ‘State of Food Security and Nutrition in the World’ report by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) revealed a staggering statistic for India in 2021: an estimated 74% of the population cannot afford a healthy diet.
- Given India’s massive population of 1.4 billion, this translates to approximately one billion Indians facing food affordability challenges.
- This finding aligns with other studies within India, indicating a declining ability of households to finance their food needs, with implications for nutrition.
Plausibility of the FAO’s Findings
- A study conducted in Mumbai between 2018 and 2023 highlights the increasing cost of preparing a traditional meal (“thaali”) at home, which rose by 65%.
- In dissimilarity, the average wages of both manual and salaried workers increased by 38% and 28%, respectively, during the same period.
- This income-food price gap implies reduced purchasing power and potentially lower food consumption.
- Furthermore, the rise in anaemia prevalence, mostly linked to nutrient deficiencies, as indicated by the National Family Health Survey conducted over 2019-21, reinforces the plausibility of FAO’s findings.
- Over 50% of adult women were estimated to be anaemic, underscoring the nutritional challenges faced by a significant portion of the population.
The Need for a Supply-Side Intervention
- Traditional macroeconomic policies, including those aimed at controlling inflation, have not proven effective in addressing food-price inflation.
- The Reserve Bank of India’s approach of reducing output in response to rising inflation, misleadingly termed “inflation targeting,” does not address the root causes of food inflation, mainly stemming from supply-side issues.
- Central banks alone cannot resolve this complex problem, necessitating a different approach focused on increasing agricultural productivity.
Learning from the Green Revolution
- India’s history includes the successful Green Revolution of the 1960s, a supply-side response to food shortages that significantly increased food production.
- This achievement was instrumental in making India self-reliant in food production. However, it came with some drawbacks, such as overreliance on chemical fertilizers and limited attention to protein sources.
- Instead of dwelling on past mistakes, there is a need to initiate a second agricultural revolution, aiming to lower the cost of producing food.
Initiatives for a Second Agricultural Revolution
To achieve a second agricultural revolution, several initiatives are crucial:
- Expansion of Irrigation: Ensuring 100% irrigation coverage of the net sown area.
- Land Leasing: Removing restrictions on land leasing to encourage capital investment.
- Agricultural Research: Reinvigorating public agricultural research institutes.
- Extension Services: Re-establishing extension services for disseminating best practices.
- Protein Production: Focusing on increasing protein production to address nutritional deficiencies.
Role of States and Cooperative Federalism
- States’ involvement is pivotal in executing these initiatives. Collaborative efforts between the central and state governments, following a spirit of cooperative federalism, are necessary.
- States should also prioritize enhancing agricultural productivity rather than solely relying on central food allocations.
- A non-ideological approach that combines public and private enterprise, as seen during the Green Revolution, is essential for success.
Conclusion
Addressing India’s escalating food-price inflation and the resulting nutritional crisis is a pressing economic and social challenge. A supply-side intervention, akin to a second agricultural revolution, is imperative.
By learning from the successes and shortcomings of the Green Revolution and involving both central and state governments, India can work toward ensuring that all its citizens have permanent access to a healthy diet while preserving ecological security.
Navigating the AI Frontier: Balancing Promise and Control
Introduction
- The G20 Delhi Declaration emphasizes the significance of responsible artificial intelligence (AI) practices, highlighting key principles such as the protection of human rights, transparency, fairness, and accountability.
- It also acknowledges the recent commitment by G7 nations to draft an international AI code of conduct that encourages voluntary commitments from companies to prevent harm.
- The declaration mentions approximately 700 policy instruments under discussion to regulate AI, with a general consensus on regulatory principles, though concerns persist about control.
The Ascendancy of AI
- The G20 Declaration acknowledges the transformative impact of AI, citing Stanford’s Artificial Index Report of 2023, which reveals a remarkable 18-fold increase in private investment in AI since 2013 and a doubling of company adoption since 2017.
- McKinsey’s projection of AI’s annual value ranging from $17.1 trillion to $25.6 trillion underscores its immense potential. However, the declaration emphasizes that along with its promise, AI also carries significant risks.
Challenges Posed by AI
- The document recognizes the well-documented challenges posed by AI, including biased models, privacy concerns, and opaque decision-making, which affect various sectors.
- It also highlights the risks associated with generative AI, which can disrupt public discourse by spreading misinformation and disinformation.
- Additionally, the integration of AI into national defense systems raises concerns about unanticipated military escalations due to AI’s inexplicable behaviors.
The Specter of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI)
- The G20 Declaration underscores the looming danger of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI).
- Concerns revolve around the possibility of rogue AI systems, potentially hijacked by malicious actors, autonomously advancing their capabilities without control, posing serious risks in the future.
Global Interventions in 2023
- In response to these challenges, the declaration mentions two significant interventions in 2023: the draft EU AI Act and the US’s voluntary safeguards framework, introduced in collaboration with seven AI firms.
- These interventions represent initial steps toward addressing AI-related risks and responsibilities.
Balancing Progress and Control
- The G20 Declaration underscores the need to strike a balance between advancing AI’s competence and maintaining control over its development.
- It likens this balance to the importance of control rods in nuclear reactor development.
- While acknowledging AI’s potential, the declaration emphasizes the complexity of the challenges it presents.
Recommendations for a Responsible AI Future
The declaration proposes several recommendations to navigate the AI landscape responsibly:
- International Consensus on AI Risks: The need for a worldwide consensus on AI risks is stressed, with the suggestion of establishing an international commission focused on identifying AI-related risks iteratively.
- Standards for Public AI Services: The declaration calls for the conceptualization of standards to be met by all public AI services. These standards would enhance safety, quality, efficiency, and interoperability on an international level.
- Public Involvement in AI: The document highlights the importance of states having a significant stake in AI’s design, development, and deployment, which is currently dominated by a few companies. It suggests reimagining public-private partnership models and creating regulatory sandbox zones for equitable solutions to societal challenges.
Conclusion
The G20 Delhi Declaration recognizes the immense potential and challenges of AI. It emphasizes the need for creativity, humility, and responsibility in AI development, ultimately emphasizing the importance of control and foresight in shaping AI’s future.