Decline of Modern Indian Political Thought
Introduction
- Topic Overview: The decline of modern Indian political thought is a significant concern that reflects on the poverty of political imagination, understanding, and judgement in contemporary India.
- Relevance: This decline impacts political vision, analysis, and strategy, essential for meaningful political action and national progress.
- Understanding Political Thought
- Definition: Political thought encompasses reflections on politics that transcend daily commentary, ideological debates, or policy suggestions.
- Core Questions:
- Vision: What kind of political order do we aspire to create?
- Analysis: What is our current political status relative to our goals?
- Strategy: How do we transition from our present state to our desired political future?
- Historical Context
- Modern Indian Tradition: Flourished from the 1870s to the 1960s, featuring a diverse range of thinkers who addressed these core questions.
- Influence: Their ideas influenced the anti-colonial struggle, the Constitution, and post-colonial politics. Thinkers were often political activists with deep roots in regional contexts and languages.
- Current State
- Decline: Post-1960s, there has been a noticeable decline in this tradition, leading to a void in political imagination and judgment.
- Exceptions:
- Feminism: Expands beyond the traditional women’s question, addressing intersections with caste, class, and LGBTQ rights.
- Social Justice: Discussions have broadened to include issues like caste, race, and the conditions of marginalized communities.
- Critiques of Development: Debates on alternatives to development focus on ecological concerns and new economic orders.
- Responses to the Decline
- Nitin Pai: Attributes the decline to specific causes, prompting further discussion.
- Professor Ashutosh Varshney: Suggests that while political science has advanced, it should not replace the need for visionary political thought.
- Professor Shruti Kapila: Argues that political ideas are alive but may be found in unconventional places or by new thinkers.
- Criticisms and Omission
- Scope of Thinkers: Initial lists of thinkers were criticized for omissions, including influential figures like Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, Aruna Asaf Ali, and others.
- Broader Inclusion: Acknowledges the need to include a wider array of thinkers from various ideological and academic backgrounds.
Conclusion
- Call to Action: The discussion is not merely about lamenting the decline of political thought but about actively engaging in collective deliberation to revive and reinvigorate this essential aspect of political life.
- Objective: To restore a vibrant tradition of political thinking that can address the complex questions of political vision, analysis, and strategy for India’s future.
Mains Practice Question
|
1. Discuss the decline of modern Indian political thought and its implications for contemporary political action. How can this tradition be revived to address current political challenges?
|
Unified Pension Scheme and Cooperative Federalism
Introduction
- Topic Overview: The Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) represents a significant reform in pension management for government employees. It has broader implications for cooperative federalism and fiscal prudence.
- Relevance: The adoption of UPS by states like Maharashtra and the benefits it provides in terms of pension predictability and fiscal management highlight its importance in the current political and economic landscape.
- Overview of the Unified Pension Scheme (UPS)
- Key Features:
- Pension Certainty: Guarantees 50% of the average basic pay in the last 12 months of service as pension.
- Retained Reforms: Maintains the contributory and funded nature of pensions introduced during Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s tenure.
- Key Features:
- Contrast with Old Pension Scheme (OPS):
- OPS Characteristics: Non-contributory and unfunded, leading to potential long-term fiscal burdens for states.
- Recent Trends: Some states reverted to OPS to avoid immediate financial strain, risking future fiscal stability.
- Impact on Cooperative Federalism
- State Adoption: Maharashtra’s adoption of UPS reflects a commitment to cooperative federalism and fiscal prudence.
- Encouragement for Other States: Maharashtra’s move may prompt other states to adopt UPS, ensuring uniform pension policies and financial stability.
- Fiscal Implications
- Economic Analysis:
- RBI Report: Highlights the enormous fiscal cost of reverting to OPS, with potential pension burdens increasing significantly compared to the New Pension Scheme (NPS).
- Long-Term Benefits: UPS provides a balanced approach, combining immediate pension certainty with long-term fiscal sustainability.
- State Finances: The UPS framework supports states in maintaining fiscal space for capital expenditure, fostering infrastructure development and economic growth.
- Economic Analysis:
- Supportive Measures for States
- Increased Capital Investment Assistance:
- Special Assistance: The Ministry of Finance has increased special assistance for capital investment, providing Rs 1 lakh crore in interest-free loans, now raised to Rs 1.3 lakh crore.
- Purpose: To complement state budgets and encourage capital expenditure beyond normal borrowing ceilings.
- Transparency in Borrowings:
- New Measures: Addressing past practices of off-budget borrowings, which pushed state finances to their limits. Improved transparency aims to prevent fiscal mismanagement.
- Increased Capital Investment Assistance:
- Political Reactions and Opposition
- Contradictory Responses: Opposition parties have shown inconsistent stances on UPS, lacking a coherent policy response.
- Call for Responsibility: Emphasis on the need for national parties to adopt a responsible and unified approach on key national issues, including fiscal policies.
Conclusion
- Summary of Benefits: The UPS offers a win-win solution by ensuring predictable pensions while preserving the contributory and funded nature of the scheme. It also aligns with the goals of cooperative federalism by encouraging states to adopt a fiscally responsible framework.
- Far-Reaching Implications: Beyond pension reforms, the UPS is part of a broader strategy to enhance capital investment, ensure transparency in state finances, and foster cooperative federalism. This reflects Prime Minister Modi’s commitment to balanced and sustainable governance.
Mains Practice Question
|
1. Evaluate the implications of the Unified Pension Scheme (UPS) for cooperative federalism and state finances in India. How does the scheme address the challenges posed by the Old Pension Scheme (OPS) and contribute to fiscal stability?
|
